Tuesday, January 19, 2010

Yahya Snow Challenged to Debate the Trinity

See the following blog posts on my debate challenge to Yahya Snow:

My Challenge

Yahya's Response

My Reply

Anyone interested in seeing this debate go forward, please contact Yahya Snow and encourage him to accept both the challenge and the debate topic.


Hogan Elijah Hagbard said...

Have you had any correspondance with Yahya Snow lately?

He uploaded an entire youtube video on me, which I have responded to in writing. I posted the links to his youtube on the comment section of his blog (which he never allowed to be viewed), but now he has even removed all the comment sections. I find this deplorable since his readers or viewers are told only that Hogan Elijah Hagbard believes Islam to be demonic, without being provided the reason why I hold to such a view or being introduced to the context in which the comment was uttered or even a link to the blogs I run or contribute to.

Utterly disturbing and deplorable and these people complain about being censored or banned from www.answeringmuslim.com

But how do you guys correspond concerning your future debate on the Trinity?

Semper Paratus said...

Hey Hogan,

I've seen Yahya's latest antics regarding you. He has continued to censor my comments as well and has never contacted me by e-mail. He has become altogether silent on the issue of my debate proposal.

Yahya is demonstrating by his actions that he does not believe Islam can prevail in the arena of open debate. But we already knew that.

GreekAsianPanda said...

Just wondering, but why was Yahya Snow banned from the Answering Muslims blog? What did he do?

Semper Paratus said...

Greetings GreekAsianPanda,

There were several things that led up to Yahya being banned.

When he first started visiting and commenting on AM he made several slanderous remarks about David Wood, saying he was a liar and deceiver, etc. (When Yahya tells the story of his banning he conveniently neglects to tell this part of it.)

Yahya did other things as well, but the final straw came when he tried to upbraid David for not personally notifying him about a post that was put up on Answering Muslims, a site that Yahya frequented daily at the time. Not only is David not under obligation to act like Yahya's dhimmi by sending him personal memo's everytime he posts something, but why would David even think he needed to tell Yahya something that Yahya would have been able to see for himself since he was a frequent visitor? It isn't like David posted a reply that was only available to insiders who have a secret decoder ring. In fact, that's just it: Yahya did see the response for himself; that's the whole reason he knew there was a response in the first place. But even after being warned by David to stop carrying on like he was in a position to impose his trumped up strictures on him, he continued to berate David for violating the rules he laid down for him.

There is more to this story, but the bottom line is that Yahya wasn't banned because of any arguments that he was putting forward; it was completely for behavioral reasons. Indeed, as you can see by the fact that he is ducking my debate challenge and Hogan's responses, Yahya is the one who fears the arguments of others and doesn't want his handful of followers to know he has been debunked...repeatedly.

Hogan Elijah Hagbard said...

I think I am gona summarize this whole thing into a post and expose this typical trend.

Yahya Snow said...

Greek Asian Panda...

I have discussed my banning in my response to Semper Paratus's debate challenge.


I do intend to iron out the details of the debate...give me time, please (I am extremely busy at the moment and have a backlog of responses I need to churn out before moving onto a written debate with you...patience is the buzz word here my friend)

@ Hogan..

Removing my comment section TEMPORARILY (until something more practical can come to fruition) is not censorship of your material...your material is on D.Wood's blog...a blog which reaches more people than most other blogs...so your message is getting out there. I intend to respond later on...give me time...please


PS..if you want to message me youcan contact me on my YouTube page


May God help Haiti...ameen

Sepher Shalom said...


Did you stop following Yahya's blog, or did he remove you as a follower?

I was thinking that perhaps since he shut down the comments section on his blog, you may have lost interest in following it.

Semper Paratus said...

Hey Sepher,

I got a little fed up with Yahya's antics. I stopped "following" his site officially, but I still pop in to see what he is up to.

I am aware of his latest on John 1:19ff. I may respond for Sam since he is busy, but I have held off (for a time) in the hopes that Yahya may accept my debate challenge. If I chime in again on the John 1 issue, Yahya may use it as an excuse to further delay the proposed debate. We will see. He's already stalled for quite some time.

Louis Farrakhan said...

When commenting with YOYO SNOWBALLS, its best to hit him with a baseball bat a few times, to get his attention.

Muhammadans remind me of CAMELS - UGLY, STUBBORN & BAD TEMPERED.

Trying to reason with a STUBBORN CAMEL, is on par with trying to discuss MUHAMMADANISM with a BUTT SNIFFER.


A Fartwa on farting in the mosque
Islam Q & A:
She passes wind continually; does this mean she cannot go to the mosque?
Am I not allowed to pray in the mosque, because I suffer from constant emission of wind that does not have a smell? How often do I have to do wudoo’ in order to offer obligatory and naafil prayers?.